Gove admits foreign power will have jurisdiction over UK territory from 01 Jan
Boris & Ursula talks: “Frank” says no.10, “lively” says the EU. Four days until “walk away”?
Brexit Facts4EU analyses yesterday’s events in Westminster and Brussels
Yesterday, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and Minister for the Cabinet Office the Rt Hon Michael Gove MP made an extraordinary statement in the House of Commons. In his opening remarks he stated:
“Throughout 2020, we have worked intensively to ensure that the withdrawal agreement, in particular the Northern Ireland protocol, will be fully operational on 1 January 2021.”
This is the Withdrawal Agreement which effectively partitions the UK and grants a foreign power legal rights in the UK’s sovereign territory. Not only is the UK Government apparently still accepting this broken agreement, it seems that it has been working 'intensively' to implement it. As he went on, Mr Gove stated:
“The agreement also respects the protocol provisions, which were endorsed by Parliament, that allow some EU officials to be present at Northern Ireland ports as UK authorities carry out our own procedures.”
In short, officials from a foreign power will have the right to be on British soil, supervising UK government officials. He then confirmed that the measures the Government had taken with the Interim Markets Bill to negate the power of the EU were now being withdrawn, as well as further UK protections which had been planned for the finance bill.
“Of course, the agreement we have reached also enables the Government to withdraw clauses 44, 45 and 47 of the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill and avoids the need for any additional provisions in the Taxation (Post-transition Period) Bill.”
Mr Gove was then asked questions - here's one from the Rt Hon Dr Liam Fox MP
Fox: “As it now stands, is there any part of the withdrawal agreement that requires direct application of EU law to any part of the UK?”
Gove: “Yes, it is the case that as a result of some of the provisions in the Northern Ireland protocol, there will be a requirement on some businesses in Northern Ireland specifically to follow the acquis.”
The ‘acquis’ is the EU’s body of laws, directives, and regulations. Mr Gove didn't say so, but these will also apply to businesses in England, Scotland and Wales in respect of state aid provisions.
Mr Gove was pressed on this point by Richard Drax MP:
Drax: “…my right hon. Friend has said on many occasions that we must leave together. In answering questions … he said—unless I am incorrect—that EU law will apply in Northern Ireland, as will the European Court of Justice. We have gone to all this effort to be free of those structures. Can he say whether I have got it wrong or he has got it wrong—one or the other?”
Gove: “My hon. Friend never gets it wrong, and he is right. It is there in the withdrawal agreement and in the protocol that we accept the acquis in a specific number of areas in Northern Ireland. That is part of the withdrawal agreement…”
Mr Gove’s reply confirmed the case that EU law will apply in Northern Ireland. He was silent on the impact on businesses in mainland GB which export to NI.
From Westminster to Brussels
Below we publish the short statements from each side, following the Prime Minister’s flying visit to have dinner with EU Commission President von der Leyen yesterday evening.
“The Prime Minister and President von der Leyen met for dinner in Brussels this evening.
“The leaders had a frank discussion about the state of play in the negotiations. They acknowledged that the situation remained very difficult and there were still major differences between the two sides.
“They agreed that Chief Negotiators would continue talks over the next few days and that a firm decision should be taken about the future of the talks by Sunday.
“The Prime Minister is determined not to leave any route to a fair deal untested, but any agreement must respect the independence and sovereignty of the UK.”
© EU Commission
“We had a lively and interesting discussion on the state of play across the list of outstanding issues.
“We gained a clear understanding of each other´s positions. They remain far apart. We agreed that the teams should immediately reconvene to try to resolve these essential issues.
“We will come to a decision by the end of the weekend.”
Ever since the first version of the abominable Withdrawal Agreement was published we have condemned it as totally unacceptable. Our condemnation continued up to and including the re-negotiation conducted by Mr Johnson and his team late last year. The final version was signed by Mr Johnson on 24 January this year (2020).
The Withdrawal Agreement including its Northern Ireland Protocol partitions the United Kingdom, gives EU law supremacy over UK law, and breaks the Good Friday Agreement – amongst its many other serious flaws.
Yesterday in Parliament Michael Gove was forced to concede that our position, long held, is correct on all the issues he was questioned about. This simply isn’t Brexit.
We have one question for Mr Gove
Following his negotiations with the EU, is the Withdrawal Agreement and its Northern Ireland Protocol now to be redrafted, replaced, or rescinded completely? If not, then under the legal arrangements of this agreement the United Kingdom is neither united nor sovereign.
This is fact. No amount of sophistry (at which Mr Gove is certainly an expert) can pull the wool over anyone’s eyes. This is a Brexit sell-out.
Four more days?
Regarding the dinner between the Prime Minister and the EU Commission President, what is there to say? Yet another deadline has been set: Sunday night. Four more days of pointless dialogue between Monsieur Barnier and Lord Frost.
And at today’s EU Summit of the leaders of all 27 EU countries, the UK-EU trade deal isn’t even on the agenda.
If you found this article enlightening and useful, please donate something to us now. We need public donations to continue our work and we receive nothing from other sources. Quick, secure, and confidential links are below this article. We really need your help today. Thank you so much if you can help to keep us going.
[ Sources: UK Parliament (Hansard) | No.10 | EU Commission ] Politicians and journalists can contact us for details, as ever.
Brexit Facts4EU.Org, Thur 10 Dec 2020
Please scroll down to COMMENT on the above article.
And don't forget to actually post your message after you have previewed it!
Since before the EU Referendum, Brexit Facts4EU.Org
has been the most prolific researcher and publisher of Brexit facts in the world.
Supported by MPs, MEPs, & other groups, our work has impact.
We think facts matter. Please donate today, so that we can continue to ensure a clean Brexit is finally delivered.
Paypal Users Only - Choose amount first